Before a New York Surrogate's Court will admit a will to probate, every person the law treats as interested must either be served with a citation or sign a waiver. That rule comes from Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 1403, and it is the reason a probate petition can sit for weeks while the executor collects signatures from siblings, nieces, nephews and other relatives.

Who must receive process in a New York probate proceeding?

Under SCPA § 1403, process must issue to the testator's distributees and to several other categories of people, unless they are themselves petitioners. Under New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 1-2.5, a distributee is a person entitled to take or share in a decedent's property under the statutes governing descent and distribution. The statute does not limit this to distributees who are left out of the will, so they receive process even when the will leaves them nothing. If you are unsure who counts as a distributee, our article on dying without a will in New York walks through the order of inheritance.

"In a proceeding for the probate of a will process must issue to the following persons if not petitioners: (a) The distributees of the testator."

— New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 1403(1)(a)

The same section lists other people who must be served. In plain terms, they are:

If a person who must be served has died, SCPA § 1403(1)(h) requires process to issue to that person's fiduciary, and if none has been appointed, to the people interested in that person's estate as distributees, nominated fiduciaries, or legatees or devisees under any will of the deceased filed in the court. A sibling who died after the testator does not drop off the list; the sibling's estate takes that place.

SCPA § 1403(2) also controls what the process says: it must set forth the name of the proponent, and if the will is nuncupative, that fact. Under EPTL § 3-2.2, a will is nuncupative when it is unwritten.

What is a citation in Surrogate's Court?

A citation is the process the Surrogate's Court issues to bring an interested person into the proceeding; it tells that person who is offering the will and when the matter is returnable in court. SCPA Article 3 governs how process is served and when the citation is returnable. SCPA § 308 is titled "Return day of citation", and it sets the minimum number of days between service and the court date.

Under SCPA § 308(1)(a), the citation must be served at least:

Those periods run from the time service is complete as provided in SCPA § 309. A relative living abroad therefore pushes the earliest possible return day further out, which is one of the practical reasons probate timelines vary. Our guide on how long probate takes in New York covers the other factors.

How is a citation served under SCPA § 307?

SCPA § 307 permits service by personal delivery, by registered or certified mail, by special mail service, or in a manner directed by the court. Personal delivery and mail service work both inside and outside New York.

"Service of the process may be made on any person by personal delivery of a copy of the process either within or without the state."

— New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 307(1)

Court-ordered service under SCPA § 307(3) is the fallback. For a domiciliary natural person, the court will not order it unless it is shown that, with due diligence, personal or mail service cannot be effected, or that such service would be impracticable for good cause. The statute lets the court consider the size of the estate and the remoteness of kinship of the person to be cited when deciding how much diligence is enough. The methods the court may direct include:

Minors and incapacitated relatives

Service on a minor follows SCPA § 307(4). Process is served on the child's father, mother, guardian, an adult with care and control of the child or with whom the child resides, or a person the court directs; if the child is 14 or older, the child is also served in person. For an incompetent, a conservatee, or an entity, SCPA § 307(5) makes listed CPLR service provisions apply unless the SCPA or the court provides otherwise.

How does a waiver of process work under SCPA § 401?

A waiver is a signed, acknowledged document by which an adult, competent interested person gives up issuance and service of the citation and appears in the proceeding without being served. Once filed with the clerk, it counts the same as an acknowledged notice of appearance.

"Any adult competent party may also appear by an acknowledged waiver of issuance and service of process which upon filing with the clerk is equivalent to the filing of an acknowledged notice of appearance under subdivision 2. In a probate proceeding the waiver shall state the date of the will to which it relates and that a copy has been furnished or examined."

— New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 401(4)

Three practical points follow from that text:

  1. It must be acknowledged. An unsigned email or a text saying "I'm fine with it" is not a waiver.
  2. It is tied to one will. The waiver states the date of the will it relates to. If a different or later instrument is offered, the waiver for the earlier one does not carry over automatically.
  3. The signer must have seen the will. The waiver states that a copy has been furnished or examined. Sending each distributee a copy with the waiver avoids a later dispute about what they agreed to.

Section 401(4) extends the waiver to an adult competent party. A minor is reached through service under § 307(4), as described above.

A waiver does not replace the court's own review. SCPA § 1408(1) requires the court, before admitting a will to probate, to "inquire particularly into all the facts" and be satisfied with the genuineness of the will and the validity of its execution. Signed waivers from every distributee make a proceeding faster, but the Surrogate still examines the will.

What happens if a distributee will not sign the waiver?

If a distributee refuses to sign, the petitioner serves that person with a citation, and the proceeding moves forward on the court's schedule rather than the relative's. A refusal does not block probate. It changes the procedure: the executor arranges service under SCPA § 307, waits out the minimum period under § 308, and the matter comes before the court on the return day.

What the relative can do on or before the return day depends on SCPA § 1410. Any person whose interest would be adversely affected by admission of the will may file objections, and the statute sets the deadline.

"The objections must be filed on or before the return day of the process or on such subsequent day as directed by the court; provided however that if an examination is requested pursuant to 1404, objections must be filed within 10 days after the completion of such examinations, or within such other time as is fixed by stipulation of the parties or by the court."

— New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) § 1410

Under SCPA § 1404(4), any party, before or after filing objections, may examine the attesting witnesses and the person who prepared the will, and in some circumstances others. This pre-objection examination is how a distributee who suspects a problem tests the will before committing to a contest.

A relative who simply refuses to sign, then lets the return day pass without objecting, has not used the window § 1410 provides, unless the court sets a later date. A relative who does object turns the probate into a contested proceeding. Our guide on contesting a will in New York covers what follows.

Practical steps when a relative is holding out

For the wider structure of the SCPA and where Article 3 and Article 14 fit, see our SCPA guide to New York Surrogate's Court.

Talk to us about your probate filing

If you are an executor collecting waivers, or a relative who has received a citation and is deciding whether to sign or object, Estate Law New York can review the papers with you. Alan Vaitzman, Esq., Managing Attorney, meets clients at our office on the 17th Floor, 299 Broadway, New York, NY 10007. Schedule a free consultation at estatelawnewyork.com/contact.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to notify my siblings if they are not in the will?

If your siblings are distributees of the decedent, yes. SCPA § 1403(1)(a) requires process to issue to the testator's distributees unless they are petitioners, whether or not the will leaves them anything.

What is a waiver of citation in New York probate?

It is an acknowledged document by which an adult competent party gives up issuance and service of process. Under SCPA § 401(4), once filed with the clerk it is equivalent to an acknowledged notice of appearance, and in probate it must state the date of the will and that a copy has been furnished or examined.

What happens if a family member refuses to sign the probate waiver?

The petitioner serves that person with a citation under SCPA § 307 instead. The person may then file objections on or before the return day, or on a later day the court directs, under SCPA § 1410.

How many days before the court date must a citation be served?

Under SCPA § 308, at least 10 days for personal delivery within New York, 20 days for service within the United States by other than personal delivery, and 30 days in all other cases or where the attorney general is a party.

Can a citation be served if we cannot find a relative?

Yes, the court can direct an alternative method such as publication under SCPA § 307(3). For a domiciliary natural person, the court must first be shown that personal or mail service cannot be made with due diligence, or would be impracticable for good cause.

Can a minor sign a probate waiver?

SCPA § 401(4) allows waivers by an adult competent party. A minor is served under SCPA § 307(4) through a parent, guardian or other listed adult, and a child 14 or older is also served in person.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this publication. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reviewed by Alan Vaitzman, Esq. — Managing Attorney at Estate Law New York. Working in estate law since 2017. J.D., New York Law School (2021); B.A. in Psychology, Brooklyn College (2016). Admitted to practice in New York (Reg. No. 5989199), New Jersey, and Florida (Bar No. 1040681). Office: 299 Broadway, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10007.