Decanting is the process by which a trustee moves principal out of an existing irrevocable trust and into a new trust with different terms. In New York, the trustee's authority to do this comes from Section 10-6.6 of the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL). The statute calls the old trust the "invaded trust" and the new one the "appointed trust", and it sets out who may decant, how far the new terms may depart from the old ones, who must receive notice, and a list of things decanting may never be used to accomplish.

What is decanting under EPTL § 10-6.6?

Decanting is a trustee's exercise of a power to invade trust principal by paying it to the trustee of another trust instead of to a beneficiary. EPTL § 10-6.6(s)(6) defines the invaded trust as "any existing irrevocable inter vivos or testamentary trust whose principal is appointed under paragraph (b) or (c) of this section", so the statute reaches both lifetime trusts and trusts created under a will. The receiving trust must also be irrevocable: under § 10-6.6(s)(1), the appointed trust "means an irrevocable trust which receives principal from an invaded trust".

For a broader comparison of the two kinds of trust involved, see our article on revocable vs. irrevocable trusts in New York.

Which trustee is allowed to decant?

Only an "authorized trustee" may decant, and the definition excludes the trust's creator and a trustee who is also a beneficiary. Under § 10-6.6(s)(2), an authorized trustee is "any trustee or trustees with authority to pay trust principal to or for one or more current beneficiaries other than (i) the creator, or (ii) a beneficiary to whom income or principal must be paid currently or in the future, or who is or will become eligible to receive a distribution of income or principal in the discretion of the trustee (other than by the exercise of a power of appointment held in a non-fiduciary capacity)."

Three further points from the statute shape when the power may be used:

What can a trustee with unlimited discretion change?

A trustee with unlimited discretion over principal may appoint to a new trust for some or all of the current beneficiaries, leaving others out. That is the core of § 10-6.6(b):

"An authorized trustee with unlimited discretion to invade trust principal may appoint part or all of such principal to a trustee of an appointed trust for, and only for the benefit of, one, more than one or all of the current beneficiaries of the invaded trust (to the exclusion of any one or more of such current beneficiaries)."

— New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 10-6.6(b)

The successor and remainder beneficiaries of the new trust may likewise be "one, more than one or all of the successor and remainder beneficiaries of such invaded trust".

Whether a trustee's discretion is "unlimited" turns on the definition in § 10-6.6(s)(9): "the unlimited right to distribute principal that is not modified in any manner." The same subparagraph provides that "[a] power to pay principal that includes words such as best interests, welfare, comfort, or happiness shall not be considered a limitation or modification of the right to distribute principal."

What if the trustee's discretion is limited?

A trustee who has the power to invade principal but without unlimited discretion may still decant, but the beneficiaries cannot change. Section 10-6.6(c) requires that "the current beneficiaries of the appointed trust shall be the same as the current beneficiaries of the invaded trust and the successor and remainder beneficiaries of the appointed trust shall be the same as the successor and remainder beneficiaries of the invaded trust."

The distribution standard carries over as well. Under § 10-6.6(c)(1), the appointed trust "shall include the same language authorizing the trustee to distribute the income or invade the principal of the appointed trust as in the invaded trust."

One thing a limited-discretion trustee can change is the length of the trust. Section 10-6.6(e) allows the appointed trust to have "a term that is longer than the term set forth in the invaded trust, including, but not limited to, a term measured by the lifetime of a current beneficiary." For the extended period only, § 10-6.6(c)(2) permits language giving the trustees unlimited discretion to invade principal.

Can the trust document or the creator's intent block a decanting?

Yes. An express prohibition in the trust instrument, or substantial evidence of the creator's contrary intent, will block it. Section 10-6.6(m) allows the power to be exercised "unless expressly prohibited by the terms of the governing instrument", and adds that a general bar on amendment or revocation, or a spendthrift clause, does not prevent decanting.

Section 10-6.6(h) imposes a fiduciary duty on the trustee to act "in the best interests of one or more proper objects of the exercise of the power and as a prudent person would exercise the power under the prevailing circumstances." It also bars decanting "if there is substantial evidence of a contrary intent of the creator and it cannot be established that the creator would be likely to have changed such intention under the circumstances existing at the time of the exercise of the power."

How are beneficiaries notified, and how long do they have to object?

Beneficiaries have until the decanting takes effect, which is 30 days after service of the instrument unless everyone entitled to notice consents to an earlier date. The decanting must be in a signed, dated and acknowledged writing:

"The exercise of the power to appoint to an appointed trust under paragraph (b) or (c) of this section shall be evidenced by an instrument in writing, signed, dated and acknowledged by the authorized trustee. The exercise of the power shall be effective thirty days after the date of service of the instrument as specified in subparagraph (2) of this paragraph, unless the persons entitled to notice consent in writing to a sooner effective date."

— New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 10-6.6(j)

Under § 10-6.6(j)(2), a copy of the decanting instrument, the invaded trust and the appointed trust must go to the creator, if living; to anyone with the right to remove or replace the trustee; and to the persons interested in both trusts. Delivery is "by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, or by personal delivery or in any other manner directed by the court having jurisdiction over the invaded trust." The instrument must state whether all or only part of the principal is being appointed and, if part, "the approximate percentage of the value of the principal of the invaded trust that is the subject of the appointment" (§ 10-6.6(j)(3)).

An objection is made in writing. Section 10-6.6(j)(4) provides that a person interested in the invaded trust "may object to the trustee's exercise of the power under this section by serving a written notice of objection upon the trustee prior to the effective date of the exercise of the power." The same subparagraph adds: "The failure to object shall not constitute a consent."

Receiving the papers also does not waive the right to an accounting. Under § 10-6.6(j)(5), receipt "shall not affect the right of any person interested in the invaded trust to compel the authorized trustee who exercised the power under paragraph (b) or (c) of this section to account for such exercise". Our guide to accounting proceedings for New York fiduciaries explains how those proceedings work.

Two more deadlines apply to the trustee. Within 20 days of the effective date, the original instrument must be filed in the court having jurisdiction over the invaded trust, although under § 10-6.6(j)(6) no filing is required for a lifetime trust that "has not been the subject of a proceeding in the surrogate's court". And under § 10-6.6(j)(7), the trustee may revoke the decanting before the effective date, serving notice of the revocation the same way.

What decanting cannot do

Section 10-6.6(n) lists five things an authorized trustee may not use decanting to accomplish:

  1. Cut back a mandatory right that has already come into effect. This covers a current right to a mandatory distribution of income or principal, a mandatory annuity or unitrust interest, and a right to withdraw a percentage of the trust or a specified dollar amount, "provided that such mandatory right has come into effect with respect to the beneficiary." The statute makes an exception, subject to its other limits, for appointing to a supplemental needs trust that conforms to EPTL § 7-1.12.
  2. Reduce the trustee's own liability. Decanting may not be used "[t]o decrease or indemnify against a trustee's liability or exonerate a trustee from liability for failure to exercise reasonable care, diligence and prudence".
  3. Remove the check on the trustee. The trustee may not eliminate a provision giving another person the right to remove or replace the decanting trustee "unless a court having jurisdiction over the trust specifies otherwise".
  4. Fix asset values conclusively. Decanting may not be used "[t]o make a binding and conclusive fixation of the value of any asset for purposes of distribution, allocation or otherwise".
  5. Jeopardize tax benefits already claimed. This covers the annual exclusion, the marital and charitable deductions, direct-skip treatment, and any other specific tax benefit a contribution originally qualified for.

Other paragraphs add more limits. Under § 10-6.6(q)(1), unless a court otherwise directs, decanting may not change how trustee compensation is determined, and § 10-6.6(q)(2) provides that "[n]o trustee shall receive any paying commission or other compensation for appointing of property from the invaded trust to an appointed trust". Section 10-6.6(p) forbids decanting in violation of EPTL §§ 9-1.1, 10-8.1 and 10-8.2, and states that "any such exercise shall void the entire exercise of such power."

What should a beneficiary do after receiving a decanting notice?

Calendar the effective date, which is the deadline for a written objection, and compare the beneficiaries of the two trusts. If the trustee's discretion was limited, any change in those classes is outside § 10-6.6(c).

If a trustee appears to be using decanting to serve its own interests, the remedies discussed in our article on removing a trustee for breach may also apply.

If you are a trustee weighing a decanting or a beneficiary who has been served with one, Estate Law New York can review the trust instruments and the timeline with you. Managing Attorney Alan Vaitzman, Esq. meets clients at our office on the 17th Floor, 299 Broadway, New York, NY 10007. Schedule a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean to decant a trust in New York?

Decanting means a trustee pays principal from an existing irrevocable trust (the "invaded trust") into a new irrevocable trust (the "appointed trust") with different terms. The power comes from EPTL § 10-6.6.

Does a trustee need court approval or beneficiary consent to decant?

No. EPTL § 10-6.6(j)(1) lets the authorized trustee act without the consent of the creator or the interested persons and without court approval, although the trustee may choose to seek court approval on notice to all interested persons.

How long do I have to object to a trust decanting in New York?

You must serve a written notice of objection on the trustee before the decanting's effective date, which is 30 days after service of the instrument unless everyone entitled to notice consents in writing to an earlier date. Under EPTL § 10-6.6(j)(4), failing to object is not consent.

Can a trustee use decanting to cut a beneficiary out of a trust?

Only a trustee with unlimited discretion to invade principal can appoint to a new trust that excludes one or more current beneficiaries, under EPTL § 10-6.6(b). A trustee without unlimited discretion must keep the same current, successor and remainder beneficiaries under § 10-6.6(c).

Does a spendthrift clause stop a trustee from decanting?

No. EPTL § 10-6.6(m) says a spendthrift clause or a general prohibition on amending or revoking the trust does not preclude decanting; only an express prohibition in the governing instrument does.

Can a trustee be paid a fee for decanting a trust?

No. EPTL § 10-6.6(q)(2) bars any trustee from receiving a paying commission or other compensation for appointing property from the invaded trust to the appointed trust.

If I receive a decanting notice, do I lose my right to an accounting?

No. Under EPTL § 10-6.6(j)(5), receiving the instrument does not affect an interested person's right to compel the trustee to account for the decanting or to object to an account.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this publication. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reviewed by Alan Vaitzman, Esq. — Managing Attorney at Estate Law New York. Working in estate law since 2017. J.D., New York Law School (2021); B.A. in Psychology, Brooklyn College (2016). Admitted to practice in New York (Reg. No. 5989199), New Jersey, and Florida (Bar No. 1040681). Office: 299 Broadway, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10007.