Many New Yorkers sign a careful will and assume it decides where everything goes. It often does not. Life insurance, retirement plans, annuities and brokerage accounts registered "transfer on death" usually pass by the beneficiary form on file with the company, not by the will. New York writes that rule into the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL), mainly in § 13-3.2 and in Part 4 of Article 13. If the forms and the will point in different directions, the forms generally control those accounts, and the family is left with a plan nobody intended.
Does my will control who gets my life insurance and retirement accounts?
Generally, no. EPTL § 13-3.2(a) says that when a contract or plan names a payee or beneficiary to receive payment at death, the rights of that beneficiary are not overridden by the laws that govern wills, gifts and intestacy.
"the rights of persons so entitled or designated and the ownership of money, securities or other property thereby received shall not be impaired or defeated by any statute or rule of law governing the transfer of property by will, gift or intestacy."
— New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 13-3.2(a)In practice, this means a residuary clause leaving the rest of your estate to your children does not reach a life insurance policy that still names a sibling. The insurer pays the person on its form. The same is true if you die without a will: the intestacy rules described in our guide to dying without a will in New York do not redirect a designated benefit.
Which accounts does EPTL § 13-3.2 cover?
Section 13-3.2(a) covers two broad groups of assets. The first is payment "in money, securities or other property under a pension, retirement, death benefit, stock bonus or profit-sharing plan, system or trust". The second is money payable by an insurance company, or by a savings bank authorized to sell life insurance, under:
- an annuity or pure endowment contract;
- a policy of life, group life, or industrial life insurance;
- a policy of accident and health insurance; and
- a contract with the insurer about how policy proceeds will be paid out.
The protection holds even though you can change the form at any time. Section 13-3.2(c) states that paragraph (a) applies "although a designation is revocable or subject to change by the person who makes it". A designation is not weakened because you kept the power to rewrite it, or because the money was not yet payable when you signed.
What makes a beneficiary designation valid in New York?
A designation must be in writing, signed by you, and accepted under the plan's or insurer's own process. EPTL § 13-3.2(e) requires that a designation "must be made in writing and signed by the person making the designation" and then either:
- be "[a]greed to by the employer or made in accordance with the rules prescribed for the pension, retirement, death benefit, stock bonus or profit-sharing plan, system or trust"; or
- be "[a]greed to by the insurance company or the savings bank authorized to conduct the business of life insurance, as the case may be."
This is why a sentence in a will saying that a 401(k) goes to a named child usually accomplishes little. Section 13-3.2 does not list a will as a way to make or change these designations. The change has to be made on the plan administrator's or insurer's form and accepted under its rules. We tell clients to request written confirmation after every change and keep it with the will.
Are there limits to the beneficiary's protection?
Yes. Section 13-3.2(b) states that it "does not limit article 10 of the debtor and creditor law, articles 10-C and 26 of the tax law, or 2-1.8, 5-1.1-A or 13-3.6." Two of those cross-references matter most in estate planning:
- EPTL § 5-1.1-A is titled "Right of election by surviving spouse". Because § 13-3.2 does not limit it, a beneficiary designation that bypasses a spouse does not, by itself, cut off the spouse's election rights. See our overview of the New York probate and estate administration process for how spousal claims fit into the administration of an estate.
- EPTL § 2-1.8 covers "[a]pportionment of federal and state estate or other death taxes". Section 13-3.2 does not shield a designated benefit from the estate-tax apportionment rules of § 2-1.8.
Section 13-3.6 also stays in force. It lets a fiduciary "treat as void any act done, or disposition or agreement made in fraud of the rights of any creditor".
How do transfer-on-death brokerage accounts work in New York?
EPTL Article 13, Part 4 lets the owner of stocks, bonds or a brokerage account name a beneficiary who takes ownership at the owner's death. Under EPTL § 13-4.4, a security is registered in beneficiary form "when the registration includes a designation of a beneficiary to take the ownership at the death of the owner or the deaths of all multiple owners." Section 13-4.5 says the registration may be shown by the words "transfer on death" or "TOD", or "pay on death" or "POD", after the owner's name and before the beneficiary's.
Part 4 states plainly that this is not a gift by will:
"(a) A transfer on death resulting from a registration in beneficiary form is effective by reason of the contract regarding the registration between the owner and the registering entity and this part and is not testamentary."
— New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 13-4.9(a)Several other rules in Part 4 shape how these accounts behave:
- Nothing changes during your life. Under § 13-4.6(a), the TOD designation "has no effect on ownership until the owner's death", and the owner may cancel or change it "without the consent of the beneficiary."
- Who may use it. Section 13-4.2 limits TOD registration to sole ownership or multiple ownership "with right of survivorship, rather than as tenants in common".
- Who takes at death. Section 13-4.7 provides that ownership "passes to the beneficiary or beneficiaries who survive all owners." Multiple surviving beneficiaries hold "as tenants in common" until the security is divided.
- If no beneficiary survives. Under § 13-4.7, "the security belongs to the estate of the deceased sole owner or the estate of the last to die of all multiple owners." At that point the account goes back into the estate and passes under the will or by intestacy.
- Firms may decline. Section 13-4.8(a) states that a registering entity "is not required to offer or to accept a request for security registration in beneficiary form."
- Backup beneficiaries. Section 13-4.10 lets firms accept the letters "LDPS", standing for "lineal descendants per stirpes", so that a deceased beneficiary's descendants take that beneficiary's place.
Part 4 applies, under § 13-4.12, to registrations made by "decedents dying on or after January first, two thousand six."
Can my will change a TOD beneficiary?
Yes, but only for securities registered under Part 4, and only if the will refers specifically to the registration. EPTL § 13-4.6(b) provides:
"(b) A registration in beneficiary form can be revoked or amended by an express direction in the owner's will which specifically refers to such registration."
— New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) § 13-4.6(b)A general residuary clause is not an "express direction" that "specifically refers" to a particular registration. If you want your will to override a TOD designation, the will has to identify that account. Even then, the cleaner route is usually to change the registration directly with the brokerage firm, so the firm's records and your will say the same thing. Section 13-3.2, which governs insurance and retirement plans, has no matching provision for wills.
What happens to a beneficiary designation after divorce?
New York revokes designations in favor of a former spouse automatically, unless the governing instrument expressly says otherwise. EPTL § 5-1.4(a) revokes any revocable disposition to the former spouse, "including, but not limited to, a disposition or appointment by will, by security registration in beneficiary form (TOD), by beneficiary designation in a life insurance policy or (to the extent permitted by law) in a pension or retirement benefits plan".
The words "to the extent permitted by law" matter for retirement plans, and you should not count on the statute alone. Section 5-1.4(d)(1) also protects a payor that pays the former spouse "before the payor or other third party received written notice of the divorce". After a divorce, file new designation forms rather than waiting for the statute to sort it out.
Why must beneficiary designations be coordinated with the will?
Because the will and the forms are two separate systems, and New York law lets each one run on its own track. Section 13-3.2(a) keeps the will from reaching designated benefits, and § 13-4.9(a) treats TOD transfers as contracts rather than gifts by will. A plan works only if both point to the same people in the same shares.
The mismatches we see most often are predictable:
- A will divides the estate equally among three children, but the largest asset, a retirement account, names only one of them.
- A will creates a trust for a minor or a disabled beneficiary, but the insurance policy names that person directly, so the money never reaches the trust.
- A TOD account names a beneficiary who has died, with no contingent beneficiary, so under § 13-4.7 the account falls back into the estate and passes under the will or by intestacy.
- Designations were never updated after a marriage, a birth or a divorce.
The same coordination problem applies to revocable trusts. As we explain in our article on funding a trust in New York, a trust controls only the assets actually titled to it or payable to it.
How should I review my designations?
Start with a list of every account that pays at death, then compare each form with your will. A practical review looks like this:
- Request a current copy of the beneficiary form from each insurer, plan administrator and brokerage firm. Do not rely on your memory or an old statement.
- Confirm that a primary and a contingent beneficiary are named on each one.
- Check that shares match the will, or that any difference is intentional and documented.
- If your will creates a trust for a beneficiary, decide whether that trust, not the person, should be named on the form.
- For TOD securities, ask whether the firm accepts "LDPS" or a substitute beneficiary under § 13-4.10.
- Repeat the review after any marriage, divorce, birth, death or move of an account to a new firm.
If you are deciding between a will-based plan and a trust-based plan, our comparison of a living trust versus a will in New York covers how beneficiary forms fit into each approach.
Talk to an estate planning attorney in Manhattan
Estate Law New York reviews wills alongside insurance, retirement and TOD designations, so the documents work together. Alan Vaitzman, Esq., Managing Attorney, meets clients at our office on the 17th Floor, 299 Broadway, New York, NY 10007. Bring your will and your current beneficiary forms, and schedule a free consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does my will override the beneficiary on my life insurance policy in New York?
Generally, no. EPTL § 13-3.2(a) provides that a designated beneficiary's rights are not impaired or defeated by the laws governing transfers by will, gift or intestacy, so the insurer pays the person named on its form.
How do I change the beneficiary on my retirement plan or insurance policy?
Use the plan's or insurer's own form. EPTL § 13-3.2(e) requires a designation to be in writing, signed by you, and either agreed to by the employer or insurer or made under the plan's rules.
Can I change a transfer-on-death beneficiary in my will?
For securities registered in TOD or POD form, yes, but only by an express direction in the will that specifically refers to that registration, under EPTL § 13-4.6(b). Changing the registration directly with the brokerage firm is usually cleaner.
Does the TOD beneficiary have any rights while I am alive?
No. Under EPTL § 13-4.6(a), a TOD designation has no effect on ownership until the owner's death, and the owner can cancel or change it without the beneficiary's consent.
What happens to a TOD account if my beneficiary dies before me?
If no named beneficiary survives all owners, EPTL § 13-4.7 provides that the security belongs to the estate of the deceased sole owner or of the last surviving owner. It then passes under the will or by intestacy, which is why a contingent beneficiary is worth naming.
Is my ex-spouse still my beneficiary after a divorce in New York?
EPTL § 5-1.4 revokes revocable designations to a former spouse, including TOD registrations and life insurance designations, unless the governing instrument expressly provides otherwise. For pension and retirement plans the revocation applies only to the extent permitted by law, so file new forms after a divorce.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this publication. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Reviewed by Alan Vaitzman, Esq. — Managing Attorney at Estate Law New York. Working in estate law since 2017. J.D., New York Law School (2021); B.A. in Psychology, Brooklyn College (2016). Admitted to practice in New York (Reg. No. 5989199), New Jersey, and Florida (Bar No. 1040681). Office: 299 Broadway, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10007.